Blockbuster or Netflix? - Online Rental Comparison

Renting movies online makes sense with the average store rental costing about $5. Even if you only rent 2 movies a month, you cut your movie budget in half. Watching 2 movies a week would cost about $40 in a rental store; a $36 online plan can get you over 50 movies a month instead of 8! Free trial periods are available at both Netflix and Blockbuster.

Which one should I choose? That’s what most people want to know when looking at these two online movie rental giants. They both work the same way – you create a list of movies you want to watch, and your selections are mailed to your home in prepaid return envelopes. There are no due dates and no late fees to worry about.

The basics. There are many different plans to choose from at each place and the costs and values are basically comparable. Blockbuster and Netflix both offer a variety of plans ranging from $3.99 – $34.99 per month. The cheapest plans give you 1 DVD at a time by mail and allow 2 rentals per month. The premium plans offer 3 or 4 DVDs at a time by mail and allow unlimited rentals per month.

The extras. While each plan offers a certain number of DVDs by mail, it is the extras that are different with each online rental store. Blockbuster offers in-store movie exchanges through their local stores. When you are done with the mailed movie, stick it in the envelope and take it to your local Blockbuster store, where you can pick out a new movie to take home. Blockbuster will scan your envelope as received, allowing a new DVD to be sent to your home, and return your mailed DVD. Netflix offers movies instantly on your PC from a separate, smaller library of movies. Choose a movie from this selection to watch and it instantly starts playing on your computer.

The plans. A good place to start when deciding on a plan is to figure out how many movies you typically rent each month. Netflix offers a choice of 5 different plans and Blockbuster offers 11 different plans. Whether you watch 2 movies a month or 100 movies a month, there is a plan that fits your movie watching needs.

The plan details and associated costs are as of 5/15/2008

1 DVD at a time by mail - Limit: 2 per month

Blockbuster 3.99 * no in-store exchanges
Netflix 4.99 * plus 2 hours instantly on PC
Blockbuster 9.99 * plus 2 in-store exchanges


1 DVD at a time by mail - No Monthly Limit

Blockbuster 8.99 * no in-store exchanges
Netflix 8.99 * plus unlimited hours instantly on PC
Blockbuster 11.99 * plus 2 in-store exchanges
Blockbuster 21.99 * plus unlimited in-store exchanges


2 DVD's at a time by mail - No Monthly Limit

Blockbuster 13.99 * no in-store exchanges
Netflix 13.99 * plus unlimited hours instantly on PC
Blockbuster 16.99 * plus 3 in-store exchanges
Blockbuster 29.99 * plus unlimited in-store exchanges


3 DVD's at a time by mail - No Monthly Limit

Blockbuster 15.99 * no in-store exchanges
Netflix 16.99 * plus unlimited hours instantly on PC
Blockbuster 19.99 * plus 5 in-store exchanges
Blockbuster 34.99 * plus unlimited in-store exchanges


4 DVD's at a time by mail - No Monthly Limit

Netflix 23.99 * plus unlimited hours instantly on PC


Isn’t it time? Whether you decide Blockbuster or Netflix is right for you, sign up for a free trial period today and see how easy online renting can be. Start saving time and money today by signing up for a free trial below.

Netflix, Inc. Start Blockbuster Free Trial

Login

Email Address
Password
Forgot Password?
New Account? Create your FREE sign in

User Opinion

Awesome! I have been searching for a way to catalog my DVD collection and have tried a few, but none can compare to Movie Collector Plus. It is fast, very easy to use, thorough, and the functionality is great. I can't say enough good things about it. My collection of movies is quite large and without MCP, I'd get lost in it. Thanks again!
-- Carolyn Crowley

Testimonial

Thanks to Movie Collector Plus, movie night is a breeze. It used to take us 30+ minutes to find a movie. My friends and I would look through all my DVD's for an eternity just to find the one they wanted to see. We can now enter search criteria to find something to watch and it now only takes a couple of minutes to decide.

I've also sent some invitations to friends to view my collection online. Now that's convenience! Thanks again for helping me to get organized.
-- Mark Miller

Sponsored Links


Netflix, Inc.
 

How To Organize Movies

A large DVD collection is wonderful to own, but can be difficult to keep track of. To really appreciate your movie collection, it needs to be organized.Read More

Movie Lists

If you think you've seen them all, take a look at our suggestions before your next movie night. Read More

Online Movie Rentals

Blockbuster or Netflix? We do a head-to-head comparison of the features and plans so you know which service is best for you. Read More
Movie Collector Plus